In precision mechanics, a part must keep its dimensions and flatness for years. The machines used to work it matter, but so does the quality of the starting material.
Intense cold completes the internal transformation of the steel that began with hardening. The result is tools, dies and components that wear less and deform less.
The sections below explain what the treatment is, how it is carried out, which types exist, its advantages, its limitations and the industries where it is used.
What Is Cryogenic Treatment of Steel
Cryogenic treatment is a "cold" heat treatment: already hardened steel is brought to temperatures between −80 °C and −196 °C, held in the cold for several hours and then slowly returned to room temperature. It is followed by moderate reheating, known as tempering. It is not a coating: the cold acts on the whole part, from the surface to the core, without changing its dimensions.
The word "cryogenic" comes from the Greek kryos, meaning cold. The first industrial applications date back to the 1960s in the United States, based on research into materials for the aerospace industry. In the tooling sector, the treatment spread from the 1980s onwards.
Today it is one of the heat treatments of metals that complement hardening and tempering without replacing them.
Why Cool Steel Below Zero
During hardening, steel changes its internal structure and becomes hard: the hardened phase is called martensite. Part of the material, however, does not complete the transformation and stays in its original, softer form. This is known as retained austenite.
Retained austenite is unstable. Over time or under stress it can transform on its own, and when it does the part changes volume slightly. On a component that has already undergone precision grinding, this means dimensions that shift after inspection. Intense cold completes the transformation before the part goes into service.
How Cryogenic Treatment Works
Cryogenic treatment takes place between hardening and tempering and follows five steps, controlled by software that records the temperatures and times of each batch.
- Hardening. The steel is heated to a high temperature and cooled rapidly, producing hardened steel that is hard but not yet stable. The cold step should follow shortly afterwards to get the maximum effect.
- Slow cooling. The temperature drops gradually, by about half a degree to one degree per minute. Cooling too fast can cause cracks in the part.
- Holding in the cold. The part stays at the lowest temperature, down to −196 °C, for a period that usually ranges from 12 to 36 hours.
- Return to room temperature. Warming up is also slow, to avoid thermal shock and condensation.
- Tempering. The part is reheated to a moderate temperature chosen according to the type of steel. Tempering reduces brittleness and completes the benefits of the treatment.
What Cools the Steel
The treatment uses liquid nitrogen, which is at about −196 °C. In modern systems the parts are not immersed in the liquid: the nitrogen is sprayed into an insulated chamber and cools the air around the parts. This is known as the "dry" process, which is gentler on the material.
Temperature sensors attached to the parts measure the actual cold inside the material, not just in the chamber.
Types of Cryogenic Treatment
The types of cryogenic treatment differ according to how low the temperature goes. The more intense the cold, the longer the times and the stronger the effects.
Sub-Zero Treatment
Sub-zero treatment cools the steel to about −60/−100 °C, using dry ice or refrigeration units. It lasts a few hours and mainly serves to make the part dimensionally stable.
Where it is used: case-hardened gears and shafts, bearings, gauges and steel measuring instruments.
Deep Cryogenic Treatment
Deep cryogenic treatment goes down to −150/−196 °C with liquid nitrogen and lasts 12 to 36 hours. Besides stabilizing the part, it makes the steel's structure finer and more compact. It is the version that gives the best results against wear.
Where it is used: cutting tools, high-speed steel drills and milling cutters, punches and blanking dies.
Cryogenic Treatment of Other Metals
Cryogenic treatment of metals is not limited to steel. On aluminum, copper and cast iron, the cold mainly serves to reduce the internal stresses left by machining. The differences between steel and cast iron explain why the two iron alloys respond differently to heat treatments.
Feature | Sub-zero | Deep Cryogenic |
Minimum temperature | −60 to −100 °C | −150 to −196 °C |
Cooling method | Dry ice or refrigeneration unit | Liquid nitrogen |
Time in the cold | 1–4 hours | 12–36 hours |
Main goal | Stable dimensions over time | Less wear and stable dimensions |
Typical parts | Gears, bearings, gauges | Cutting tools, dies, punches |
Advantages and Limitations of Cryogenic Treatment
The main advantage is greater wear resistance, together with dimensions that stay more stable over time. Results do vary, however, depending on the type of steel and how the cycle was carried out.
Advantages
The most obvious benefit concerns wear, because treated tools and dies last longer. In laboratory tests the increase varies widely, from a few tens of percent up to several times the original service life, with the best results on tool steels.
The second advantage is dimensional stability. The part does not deform over time and stays within tolerance even after months of operation. In addition, hardness increases slightly and varies less from one part to the next.
Unlike a coating, the treatment acts on the whole part and not just on the surface. The benefit remains even when the tool is resharpened. Combined with tempering, it also reduces the internal stresses left by hardening and machining. As a result, tools need replacing less often and machine downtime decreases.
Limitations
Cryogenic treatment, however, does not work on all steels. On low-carbon or unhardened steels the benefit is minimal, and on the most common grades of stainless steel it brings no real advantage. Nor does it correct poorly performed hardening: if the part starts out with defects, it keeps them.
Time is another factor. Between cooling, holding in the cold and tempering, the complete cycle takes one to three days. Finally, the process must be carried out with care. Cooling too fast, sharp corners or very uneven thicknesses increase the risk of cracking, and without final tempering the part remains brittle.
